QUOTE(Rocha @ Feb 18 2012, 05:52 PM)

Rock is the New JazzArticle says rock music is going the way of the dinosaur in popular culture, but there are a lot of advantages to that.
I agree with him a little. Here's what I wrote in response:
QUOTE
I think you're right, but it will be just on a slower and smaller scale than you predict. Rock may not be the most popular genre of music anymore (though it really hasn't been for at least 10 years) but it's still rather popular all things considered and still fills arenas.
Here's one of the "problems" as I see it: There are very few interesting personalities in the rock world these days. Almost everyone is a humble, understated, scruffy young man in a button down shirt. Rock music needs the new Keith Richards, Frank Zappa, John Lennon, Keith Moon, Robert Plant, Ozzy, Kurt Kobain, Jello Biafra, Henry Rollins and so on. Nobody stands out at all. The music is still interesting as ever, but the performers are faceless.
I think the writer of this article is overblowing things. And as people point out in the comments section, he's a Jazz critic who sounds almost happy that pop and hip hop is doing to rock the same thing rock did to jazz in the 60s. But I guess the question is, do you care? We won't have less access to rock music in all its forms. With the internet, there's no lack of places to read or talk about rock music. Popular culture will ignore it, but rock was always supposed to be the dangerous one you didn't bring home to mom, anyway. But then that gets to what I wrote in the comments section: Most of the people who perform rock music these days are usually introverted, quiet, even boring.
Wait, another "Rock is Dead" article by a music critic?

Been wondering when another would pop up...it's been a while.

I remember articles like this back in the early '90s - right before Nirvana hit. The rest, yada yada yada, is history. Besides, when kids pick up guitars today, they're not playing Django; they're playing Sabbath. Rock and roll is alive and well, thank you very much.
Having said that, I do agree with him a little too -- and I don't necessarily think it's a bad thing. The problem is he's missing the bigger point: rock doesn't need to be big, because it's already taken over.
Veni Vidi Vici; it doesn't need to prove anything to anyone anymore. When Lady Gaga says that Iron Maiden is one of her favorite bands, when Rhianna employs Nuno Bettencourt in her backing band, when Mutt Lange produces country records using the same methods he used with AC/DC, and when Snoop Dogg is covering Metallica, rock's dominion is already established.
But for the sake of argument, suppose he's 100% right. Lemme revisit your comment for a sec:
QUOTE
Here's one of the "problems" as I see it: There are very few interesting personalities in the rock world these days. Almost everyone is a humble, understated, scruffy young man in a button down shirt. Rock music needs the new Keith Richards, Frank Zappa, John Lennon, Keith Moon, Robert Plant, Ozzy, Kurt Kobain, Jello Biafra, Henry Rollins and so on. Nobody stands out at all. The music is still interesting as ever, but the performers are faceless.
I totally agree.
I've always been a fan of Kiss. The makeup, goofy costumes, flashpots, Marshall amps, etc. But I also like the songs, too. Sure, the lyrics are dumb, and the song structures very basic, but it's fun, and the overall effect - the songs plus the silly theatrics -
is entertaining. This is what a lot of modern rock performers and the critics who enable them fail to understand. This is the entertainment business. Granted, the examples you listed didn't wear goofy costumes and shit, but they all had personality and charisma and weren't too concerned about appealing to the sensibilities of the general public (even if, ironically, this made them popular). They weren't afraid to do "unhip" things and even look/sound silly on occasion. Say what you want about Nicky Minaj, Gaga, Katy Perry, etc., but I admire the fact that they dont' mind looking crazy or stupid. That's more rock than anything Boniver is doing, IMO.